Can removing a tree cause foundation problems and which trees can damage foundations?

There is no denying that trees are a beneficial asset to the environment, our lifestyle and are a symbol of a healthy landscape. They create shade and privacy, contribute to better air quality, provide habitats for wildlife, and help to reduce salinity and soil erosion.

However, without proper consideration and monitoring, trees can also impact our built environment by causing damage to buildings, paths, driveways, and underground infrastructure.

A tree’s influence starts, literally, at the roots; they are responsible for keeping the tree alive by drawing essential nutrients and water from its surroundings. The roots will continue to grow as a tree matures and during this growth, the roots will extend towards anything that will maintain the tree’s life. Roots typically seek out moist soil and will often find entry into old or damaged pipes including sewer drains, sewer pipes and water mains. If a tree is removed from the soil, the foundation will be displaced due to the tree root no longer absorbing water, which could damage a building.

Seasonal change also influences how trees interact with the built environment. During the warmer months of spring and summer, soils can dry out with the lack of moisture causing reactive clays to shrink. In extreme cases, shrinking soil can lead to significant ground movement, subsidence and foundation settlement across the home. Unfortunately, trees can exacerbate this process. In their hunt for moisture, root systems will extend through dried soil, desiccating the ground and absorbing remaining water from the already dry soil. According to insurance company LV, subsidence claims have increased by 49% in the last year, although the rise is in part due to an increase in building surveys, but dry weather in the summer has largely contributed to the spike in claims.

There can be a risk of tree roots causing subsidence. The combination of dry soil and thirsty tree roots is the perfect recipe for ground movement, and the appearance of worrying subsidence symptoms, including cracks in brick walls, distorted timber frames, and doors and windows that jam. Examples of different causes of subsidence around the home, including those triggered by tree roots, can be viewed on Mainmark’s interactive house. Understanding the cause of problems is essential before a viable solution can be found.

Assessing the influence of trees

There are several factors to consider when determining whether trees could be the ‘root cause’ of damage to a home. These include:

Groupings

When trees are planted closely together, they are forced to compete for moisture and nutrients in the same area of soil. The larger the group of trees, the greater the impact on soil drying out in the surrounding area. It is therefore more likely for homes or buildings located near large groups of trees to experience effects of adverse ground conditions as the trees absorb more moisture which can contribute to greater ground movement.

Distance

As a guide, the ‘tree-to-damage distance’ set out by Cutler & Richardson (1989)[1] can be used to determine the probability of damage caused by a tree to built structures based on their distance from it. For example, the furthest distance recorded of a Willow tree damaging the foundations of a building is 40 metres, so it can be assumed that planting this type of tree 50 metres away should be a safe distance. However, you should always consult an expert if you are unsure.

Tree types

Tree activity varies across the year depending on its type, so it’s important to identify the trees that are growing near your home to know how susceptible to damage a building’s foundation is depending on the tree. Deciduous trees, for example, hibernate in winter and re-grow in spring. This lifecycle means their water demand is often highest during drier months, which has the effect of increasing the magnitude of soil shrinkage.

Characteristics

A tree’s physical characteristics can determine how much moisture its root system is likely to absorb, but it’s not always just in relation to its overall size. Research into a tree’s influence on ground conditions has indicated that it is the leaf area of the tree rather than its height that ultimately determines its moisture demand[1]. Therefore, thick or tall trees aren’t always the culprit for dry soil; it’s the amount of foliage that can indicate how much water a tree needs to sustain itself.

Surrounding environment

Roads, pavements, and larger scale developments with limited green space can also prevent moisture from reaching the soil underneath. This lack of permeability can cause dry soil conditions and may force tree roots to draw on the limited moisture available, intensifying soil shrinkage and ground movement. This is common in city areas where trees are planted for aesthetic or ‘greenscaping’ purposes, without considering the degree of exposed soil and abundance of moisture.

The risk of roots affecting the structural integrity of your property should not be a barrier to planting trees or moving to an area where trees are in abundance. Understanding tree behaviours and their relationship with the surrounding environment can help to manage their influence and reduce the likelihood of damage to the home or a commercial premises.

[1] D.F. Cutler, I.B.K Richardson (1989) Tree Roots and Buildings, Longman, London.